Obrazowanie elektryczne i magnetyczne źródeł aktywności mózgu w epilepsji: wgląd anatomiczny na podstawie realistycznych symulacji
Electric and Magnetic Source Imaging in Epilepsy: Anatomical Insights from Realistic Simulations
W skrócie
Badanie porównuje dwie metody diagnostyczne (badanie elektryczne i magnetyczne) używane do dokładnego zlokalizowania ogniska padaczki przed operacją. Okazało się, że obie metody mają różne mocne strony - badanie elektryczne lepiej wykrywa aktywność z wypukłości kory mózgowej, a magnetyczne z zagłębień między zwojami. Łączne użycie obu metod jednocześnie może dać lekarzom dokładniejszy obraz i poprawić wyniki leczenia chirurgicznego u pacjentów z padaczką oporną na leki.
Oryginalny abstract (angielski)
UNLABELLED: Neurosurgery is an effective treatment for drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE), but its success depends on the accurate delineation of the epileptogenic focus, approximated noninvasively by electric and magnetic source imaging (ESI/MSI) of high-density electroencephalography (HD-EEG) and magnetoencephalography (MEG). These modalities have distinct sensitivity profiles; consequently, epileptiform activity detected by one modality may remain undetected by the other. However, the implications of these differences for spike detectability and localization accuracy, and the added value of combined electromagnetic source imaging (EMSI), remain insufficiently characterized under clinically realistic conditions. Here, we characterize HD-EEG and MEG sensitivity profiles and compare ESI, MSI, and EMSI, using realistic simulations with known ground truth. We generated HD-EEG and MEG datasets from cortical, insular, and hippocampal sources across multiple orientations, activated using patient-derived intracranial EEG spike waveforms. Spike sensitivity and localization accuracy were evaluated using dipole scanning, dynamic statistical parametric mapping (dSPM), and linearly constrained minimum variance (LCMV). EEG demonstrated higher spike detection rates and sensitivity for radially cortical sources at gyral crowns and sulcal bottoms ( <0.001), while MEG detected more spikes from tangential cortical sources along sulcal walls ( <0.001). MSI localized tangential sources more accurately than ESI across all methods ( <0.001), while dipole scanning outperformed dSPM and LCMV for cortical and insular sources ( <0.001). EMSI outperformed ESI ( <0.001) but did not improve localization over MSI. These findings suggest that complementary anatomical sensitivities of HD-EEG and MEG may improve epileptogenic source characterization, supporting simultaneous acquisition during the presurgical evaluation of patients with DRE. KEY POINTS: EEG and MEG exhibit complementary sensitivity profiles, with EEG detecting more spikes from gyral crowns and sulcal bottoms and MEG from sulcal walls.MSI provides more focal and precise source localization than ESI, particularly for tangentially oriented sources.Dipole-based inverse method achieves higher localization accuracy than experimental dSPM and LCMV.